Referendum is not preferable on T issue, not only T issue , referendum is not preferable on any political issue in India. Referendum or plebiscite means asking voter to select choice among two- yes or no-. if T people says 'yes' to T state then state has to be formed, if t people say 'no' then state will not be formed. but it fails to solve problem on one hand and creates more problems india wide on other hand. asking for referendum means indian govt expressing its willingness to form t state if people accepts. when govt is willing to form new state then majority of people will ask for new state as they interprets referendum as an opportunity to get state irrespective of need for new state and its impact on them and on others and on india as a whole. politicians who are asking separatism will provocate people by all means during campaign resulting in crossing desired cut off mark in result. the atmosphere is already charged in t region now, in charged atmosphere decisions of people will be wrong. plebiscite will count majority voice only, then what about minority voice. even if minority voice is genuine then they will not get result in their favour. it becomes more people race rather than all people race. here criteria should be to solve all problems of all people but not whether to give state or not.
referundum is misnomer concept in reality. people's wish can be manipulated easily. so whenever people's wish changes can govt change its decision and create or merge states. if that was the case then for every five years more or less more states has to be created and merged with other states. it is not possible in reality. in t issue problem is political in nature and people has no role in it. un necessarily people are dragged in to it especially students. political problems has to be solved politically with discussions and with out any campaign/provocation etc and in peace.if a solution is reached to divide state then it can be put for referendum if need is felt with freedom to both parties separatists,unionists both with in the region to campaign for and against separation and campaign has to be peaceful and no party comes against each other and rules has to be followed.but here situation is completely reverse. from last 9 years trs is provocating people,promoting hatred, telling lies to people , naxals are directly involving in all activities, centre did wrong by dec.9 statement, attacks are going on against unionists....so plebiscite is not the option.
hyderabad, settled people in telangana from other parts of state, muslims in hyd, t region, economic interests of people from different parts of state in hyd/t region, river waters sharing, and above all trust,...problems are there .for them referendum will not give answer.
the reasons put forward by separatists for separation are baseless and not a single reason is convincing in nature.so the separation issue itself has no moral basis forget about other things.
referendum should be on broad issue only, like merge or separation of one country with other country or adoption of framing on constitution etc...only.here in t issue all problems are internal, specific .so referendum has no value here.indian people are not that much enlightened to analyse every thing and decide the fate of politicians, here politicians make,create peoples will by exploiting ignorance of people.
conducting referendum in t is not advisable on issue, referendum has to be conducted in entire ap. if that was the case then t voice will be defeated utterly. but from democracy point of view it will not be sound but facts point of view it is correct. here contradiction comes, so disputes arises. so referendum is not advisable.
if referendum is conducted on t issue in state or t region that does not matter but it will open entire country in to referendum on state formation and separation from india. pak asking for referendum in kashmir long ago, here fact is only ap has complex situation and unionists are present in t region, but in other cases almost 90% will be for separation only, how many states will indian govt will form and how many will separate from india is no answer question.ultimately there will be no india.
No comments:
Post a Comment